Showing posts with label Blogging. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Blogging. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

A comment is a terrible thing to waste

Following up from yesterday's post about Richard Schickel's anti-blog stance:

I have a fundamental disagreement with the notion that you need to have a certain level of exposure to the arts, in whatever form, to contribute a valid opinion. But one's reaction to a piece of art is always one's own. My belief is that criticism is a thorough and complete examination of a personal reaction. You don't need a bunch of classes and degrees and magazine articles and book titles to your credit to have a valid opinion about something that you experience -- you just have to be able to think about what you're seeing and to say what you feel. That has always been my contention. Anyone can get into the heavy stuff -- it just takes a little bit of effort, and, sadly, most people are not conditioned to think about the things they read/see/hear. (I guarantee you that if everyone in this country were to take a course in basic film editing techniques, they'd look at the nightly news a whole lot differently. But I digress.)

But what I think Schickel is reacting to, mostly, is the overwhelming glut of crappy writing out there. And it's true -- lots of blogs have a lot of shitty writing. Including mine. But if the Internet is now the public forum par excellence, then maybe us bloggers need to step up to the plate and take greater responsibility for the things that we dash off. If we're the future, let's earn that mantle. Be able to justify everything -- every factual error, every comma splice, everything. Without the peer-to-peer system that an editor brings to the table, most bloggers are pissing into the wind because they have no one to guide them. Let's think a bit further ahead and start learning how to guide ourselves. Look at a posting before you hit "Publish" and go, is this the best that I can do? Is it really? This ain't set in stone -- this is the Internet, after all -- but can I see myself in 10 years holding my head up and going, yeah, I stand by that?

Monday, May 21, 2007

The critic as public intellectual

Hoo baby. This one's amazing.
Let me put this bluntly, in language even a busy blogger can understand: Criticism — and its humble cousin, reviewing — is not a democratic activity. It is, or should be, an elite enterprise, ideally undertaken by individuals who bring something to the party beyond their hasty, instinctive opinions of a book (or any other cultural object). It is work that requires disciplined taste, historical and theoretical knowledge and a fairly deep sense of the author's (or filmmaker's or painter's) entire body of work, among other qualities.

Opinion — thumbs up, thumbs down — is the least important aspect of reviewing. Very often, in the best reviews, opinion is conveyed without a judgmental word being spoken, because the review's highest business is to initiate intelligent dialogue about the work in question, beginning a discussion that, in some cases, will persist down the years, even down the centuries.
Schickel's idea that the critic should be a public intellectual as well is fine, but all he's done with his ill-informed anti-blog tirade(s) is make the gap between them wider. Or try to, anyway; these kinds of spats really don't do anyone any favors. Old school versus new school, it's the same argument every time: You young whippersnappers, you don't know what you're talking about because you don't have a string of letters after your name.

There's been a big stink in the blogosphere lately (see here) over this very topic: the validity of online-based writing versus print-based. But if you think about it, it all amounts to what Nirvana once called "territorial pissings." Next topic, please.

Friday, October 06, 2006

Notes from Frankfurt

The Frankfurt Book Fair is going on as we speak. Here's some of the highlights:

Shocker.
Ditto.

Thankfully, GalleyCat is there with some real news, most notably a roundup of the big deals:
Woody Allen's MERE ANARCHY, his first collection of comic writing since his celebrated 1970s books GETTING EVEN and WITHOUT FEATHERS, will be out in August 2007, when Random House US and Ebury will publish the book at the same time. Meanwhile, Felicity Bryan has concluded 'substantial' US and French deals for the latest novel by Iain Pears with Julie Grau at Spiegel & Grau/Doubleday and Francois Triffault at Belfond. STONE'S FALL, will be delivered next year.
Meanwhile, over at the NBCC, John Freeman has gotten his hands on Against the Day. Bastard.

Friday, May 19, 2006

Indie booksellers, rest in peace

Alas, much of this piece is spot-on, even though it stings to admit it:
The real change in the book market is not the big guy vs. the little guy, or chain vs. indie stores. Rather, it's the reader's greater impatience, a symptom of our amazing literary (and televisual) plenitude. In the modern world we are more pressed for time, and we face a greater diversity of cultural choices. It was easy to finish Tolstoy's War and Peace when there were few other books around and it was hard to find them. Today, finishing it means forgoing many other options at our fingertips. As a result, we tend to consume ideas in smaller bits, a proposition that (in another context) economists labeled the "Alchian and Allen theorem." Long, serious novels are less culturally central than they were 100 years ago. Blogs are on the rise, and most readers prefer the ones with the shorter posts.
This and other corresponding stories were brought on by the news of the closing of Cody's, a venerable independent bookstore located in San Francisco. The nice thing about independently-owned and operated stores is, yes, having a personal contact at a brick-and-mortar establishment who knows a thing or two about what the store sells and can point inquisitive customers in the right direction, or, alternatively, turn them on to something they might not have thought about or heard of before.

Given the advent of the Internet, however, specialized knowledge of literature -- and books, in general -- has become almost a moot point. Word-of-mouth is one of the strongest selling points of any book, simply because it depends largely upon an interpersonal recommendation: when someone whose tastes you respect mentions a book in a positive context, you're more likely to seek it out. Cowen is smart to point out that forums on the Net -- reader reviews at Amazon, for example, as well as litblogs -- have taken this idea into a new medium. If someone over at Bookslut or Conversational Reading can make a good case for reading XY's new book, then, well, why not check it out?

Yes, e-commerce will probably be the death of the traditional independent bookstore. I'm probably like most people who like to read: my budget is limited, so I'm more likely to buy used books, or shop online for the discounts. It's extremely rare for me to pay full cover price for a book I'm looking for, be it at an independent OR chain bookstore, simply because it doesn't make a whole lot of fiscal sense to do so. It would seem, then, that the alternative to putting more money in the pockets of the behemoths is to apply the same philosophy that spurs you to shop outside the mainstream to e-commerce, as well: buying books from individuals on Amazon Marketplace or eBay, or shopping at independent online booksellers like Powells or discount retailers like BookCloseouts.com.

Cowen is right: there's more out there now, meaning more avenues to explore and about a fraction of the time to explore them. Specialized knowledge of books and literature could either become a blessing or a liability; there was a widely-circulated piece in the May 14 New York Times Magazine called "Scan This Book!", by Kevin Kelly, a writer for Wired, that suggested the future of books would be not unlike that of an MP3 playlist. Knowledge of books, Kelly suggested, would become highly compartmentalized; subject matter could be cross-indexed to death, which is fine if you're looking for scads of information on one particular topic but, as Scott Esposito pointed out, could have the backlash effect of reducing the scope and vision of a particular book to a mere collection of loosely-associated parts. Probably the most appealing thing about a well-written book of any type is its potential to compress the world in all its contradictory glory between two cardboard covers; to contain multitudes. In a world driven and governed by soundbites, that's harder and harder to accomplish.

Wednesday, March 08, 2006

Old school, new school

Two recent articles shed some light onto two much-discussed areas of the literary industry. The first was a Farhad Manjoo piece at Salon called “All the News Stuff That’s Fit to Print,” which discussed how newspapers are trying to keep up with the turning technological tide, starting with a paper target in the form of a twentysomething college student who, predictably, comes off as a bimbo:

Brown gets her news from three main sources, and each gives her a general impression of what's happening in the world. She watches "The Daily Show," which she says provides "a good grasp of what's going on." She occasionally reads the Sun-Times, Chicago's smaller competitor to the Tribune, which she likes for its size. And she frequently picks up RedEye, the free, daily commuter paper published by the Tribune and aimed at young people in Chicago.

Shaking your head at this kind of thing gets you nowhere. But, alas, newspapers have it in their head that the secret to financial success is capturing the attention of the 18-24 crowd, those fickle youngsters with lots of disposable income lying around, but they don’t seem to grasp that the advent of online communication has rendered their own product essentially extinct; by the time the printed edition hits the newsstands, its online counterpart always has more information to offer. Plus, there’s the whole notion that news has to be entertaining, which to me seems a contradiction in terms. Dumbing down the news and making it palatable to MTVites doesn’t do anyone any favors in the long run, especially when breathless tabloid reporting on celebrity escapades is seen as newsworthy.

Which is where the second article comes in. A Trevor Butterworth article at the Financial Times called “Time For The Last Post” discusses the burgeoning blogosphere, kicking off with an account of one of the strangest Vanity Fair photoshoots ever:

On a winter-cold morning last autumn, before the leaves could summon up the energy to burn and fall, the barbarians entered the gate. A group of feisty young writers, known only to millions of readers by their blog names - Gawker, Gizmodo, Wonkette and Defamer - were in a soigne studio in New York’s Chelsea district to be photographed for the February issue of Vanity Fair magazine. They represented the cream of Gawker Media - a mini-empire of clever, gossip-driven blogs launched in 2003 by Nick Denton, a former reporter for the Financial Times. But they were also emissaries from the blogging hordes, a raffish army of citizen journalists bent on overthrowing the old guard of the US media.

Tabloids are always going to be popular; everyone loves a star, but everyone loves watching a star fall even more. We’re quick to place whom we see as extraordinary on the pedestal of celebrity, but when, inevitably, someone steps out of their designated lane and acts like, you know, a regular human being, the tabloids are there to help the fall from grace along. Bloggers such as the above make this their stock in trade, and it’s fallacious to treat them as anything resembling serious journalists; popularity is not a yardstick to measure merit by. But Butterworth does go on to make a salient point:

But as with any revolution, we must ask whether we are being sold a naked emperor. Is blogging really an information revolution? Is it about to drive the mainstream news media into oblivion? Or is it just another crock of virtual gold - a meretricious equivalent of all those noisy internet start-ups that were going to build a brave “new economy” a few years ago? Shouldn’t we just be a tiny bit sceptical of another information revolution following on so fast from the last one - especially as this time round no one is even pretending to be getting rich? Isn’t the problem of the media right now that we barely have time to read a newspaper, let alone traverse the thoughts of a million bloggers?

He’s right; the sheer enormity of the information that’s available now makes most people’s brains short-circuit. But here’s the key: people seek out the information that’s important to them, whatever it is. This seeking of knowledge depends largely on your upbringing, your habits, and your conditioning. I grew up without the dubious benefit of ready access to cable television, which probably has a lot to do with my own partiality towards the written word, but I also grew up in a family that was comprised of college professors, lawyers and journalists; it was a family that was very conscious of the collision between politics, art and business. My own habits and tastes developed as a result of this atmosphere, so, people like me aren’t really the newspapers’ concern; it’s the people who grew up not reading, not talking about the world around them, and not having their thoughts and ideas discussed and challenged that are the ideal target. And unfortunately, simplistic and reductive techniques are usually the only way to reach a large amount of people.

According to Manjoo’s Salon piece, essentially the only thing keeping newspapers from putting serious effort into developing an online-only operation is the lack of a solid business model; money still has to be made. I don’t think the Internet will remain as free as it is now; online advertising, for example, has evolved from an occasional annoyance to an overwhelming eyesore to a ubiquitous, invisible standard, all within the space of a few years. The press was once seen as the people’s only voice; the so-called blogosphere is holding that mantle at the moment, but it’s not going to stay that way forever. In a capitalistic society, there’s no power greater than that of the bottom line.