Showing posts with label The New York Times. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The New York Times. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 21, 2008

Even witches mellow with age

  • Michiko reviews Updike's new sequel to The Witches of Eastwick in The New York Times.
I had no idea that this was coming out. The second surprise is that she gives it a more or less positive review.
The passage of time seems to have mellowed the witches and their creator as well, and “The Widows of Eastwick,” while deeply flawed, is a less tendentious, more emotionally credible work than its predecessor. Mr. Updike is less interested here in scoring didactic points against feminism than he is in exploring the wages of time and age shared by men and women alike, and there is an elegiac tone to the novel not dissimilar to that in the last Rabbit novel, “Rabbit at Rest” (1990). The mood here reflects his characters’ realization that the past now weighs more than the future in the scale of their lives, and that the noisy imperatives of sex, which once got them in to so much trouble, have given way to whispered worries about bodily ailments and medical woes.

Monday, April 23, 2007

Reactions to real horror

Various writers chime in on the Virginia Tech shootings.

First is the peculiar nature of the gun violence. Cho, it seems, wasn't a sniper, a marksman. He wasn't shooting carefully, at a distance. He wasn't, one can assume, aiming. He was shooting very much like Chow in the Woo pictures, with a gun in each hand, as witnesses state, up close, very fast. Woo saw gunfights in musical terms: His primary conceit was the shootout as dance number, with great attention paid to choreography, the movement of both actors within the frame. He loved to send his shooters flying through the air in surprising ways, far more poetically than in any real-life scenario. He frequently diverted to slow motion and he specialized in shooting not merely to kill, but to riddle -- his shooters often blast their opponents five and six times. Perhaps all that was at play in Cho's mind as well.
From this near-certainty Mr. Hunter makes a short trip to the assertion that during his rampage Mr. Cho “was shooting a John Woo movie in his head.” Evidence for this speculation is found in Mr. Woo’s fondness for two-fisted gunmanship, which Mr. Hunter credits him with introducing into movies, and also in a scene from “The Killer” that Mr. Hunter finds “strikingly similar to what must have happened Monday.”

It is hard to say what all this proves, other than that Mr. Hunter has no peer when it comes to wielding the conditional tense on deadline. He does not suggest that Mr. Woo is to blame for Mr. Cho’s actions. But his article does conjure a story line — the loner in his room watching ultraviolent movies on DVD, gathering inspiration for his own real-life action movie — that has unmistakable and familiar implications. Like guns, it seems, certain movies in the wrong hands can pose a threat to public safety.

This may be true, but only to the extent that a disturbed mind is apt to seek external confirmation of its own disturbance. It seems somewhat fair to conclude that Mr. Hunter, in linking Mr. Cho’s rampage to Mr. Woo’s films, was simply trying to make a guess as to the features of the killer’s mental world.
For most creative people, the imagination serves as an excretory channel for violence: We visualize what we will never actually do (James Patterson, for instance, a nice man who has all too often worked the street that my old friend George used to work). Cho doesn't strike me as in the least creative, however. Dude was crazy. Dude was, in the memorable phrasing of Nikki Giovanni, ''just mean.'' Essentially there's no story here, except for a paranoid a--hole who went DEFCON-1. He may have been inspired by Columbine, but only because he was too dim to think up such a scenario on his own.

Tuesday, April 03, 2007

The great big "if"

What a tease this must be for all concerned.

"Hi, I wrote a book that might sell."
"Hi, I'm a bookseller that might sell your book."
"My book might be worth your time and energy."
"I certainly hope so. If not, my business might suffer."
"I might not be around to apologize."
"I might not either."

This is social networking, not business.
This is the pre-publication book tour, a ritual an increasing number of authors are enduring so that their books can have a fighting chance in an industry that issues, by some estimates, more than 175,000 titles a year.

Unlike the postpublication book tour, which focuses on publicity and public appearances, the pre-publication tour is meant to win the hearts of the front-line soldiers in the bookselling trenches, and more and more publishers are finding it an indispensable part of their marketing plan.

While major decisions are left to the bookstore chains’ influential buyers, the people out in the field — the store managers and the clerks — can wield considerable power over how long books continue to be displayed on prime tables at the front of the store, and therefore over the what their customers choose to buy and read.

Tuesday, August 08, 2006

Fidelity

With books (and other such relationships in my life), I am a serial monogamist. I'm loath to read more than one at a time, and rarely have; if I'm liking what I'm reading, I finish it. It's also rare for me to bail out on a book before I finish it, although it does happen, because some books just don't ring my bell at all. (I tried to get into One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich a little while back and quit about halfway through; short as it was, it was still like watching paint dry.) Someone was looking at my bookshelf recently and asked me if I'd read all of it, and my breakdown went about like this: 60% I've read the entirety of, 20% I've read enough of to get the gist, and 20% I've yet to dive into. I collect 'em faster than I can read 'em, but that probably makes me just like every other book lover out there.
I've always been fascinated by the relationships between artists, in particular; it's like watching rival gang leaders of equal power playing a cagey chess match. Friendships between creative/intellectual types tend to be short and intense, and Epstein gets into some interesting territory:
How many intellectual friendships dissolve over conflicts of opinion and ideas cannot be known, but the number is probably at least as great as those that fall apart through such normal perils as insults (intended or not) or wounds resulting from pride, ingratitude, feelings of abandonment, or misunderstanding. Nor are intellectuals immune from the riskiest of all maneuvers in a friendship: the effort to reshape the ideas and even the character of one’s friend in one’s own image.

...With intellectuals as with anybody else, jealousy is one of the ways that friendship can sadly resemble love. It is not uncommon for two close friends to resent a third person who may seem to be coming between them—or for that third party to resent a close friendship that appears to shut him out, and to seek means of retribution. The novelist Paul Theroux, for example, blamed the breakup of his friendship with V.S. Naipaul on the latter’s marriage to a woman regarded by Theroux as aggressive and interfering. Theroux’s Sir Vidia’s Shadow (1998) was the vengeful and vitriolic result—a risible and finally unsuccessful attempt to reduce Naipaul by mocking his pretensions and highlighting his cold-bloodedness.

Theroux may possibly fall into another category—that of the person who, having no real talent for friendship himself, looks to others as ostensible friends in order to be let down by them. “He was inordinately vain and and cantankerous,” wrote Max Beerbohm about the painter James Whistler. “Enemies, as he had wittily implied, were a necessity to his nature; and he seems to have valued friendship . . . as just the needful foundation for future enmity. Quarreling and picking quarrels, he went his way through life blithely."

Monday, June 12, 2006

"Clever Tom", and more product placement

A fascinating look at one of the world's preeminent wordsmiths. It's somehow unsurprising that a chaotic, and frequently horrific, upbringing resulted in a writer best known for his wit, wordplay and narrative inventiveness. Langley's piece is refreshingly nonjudgmental, despite the colorful and sometimes salacious elements in his subject's history. It's a rare author profile that gives you a greater appreciation for the subject and their work without making you feel like you've had your nose rubbed in their dirty laundry, and Langley pulls it off:
First there were the Nazis who, when he was still little Tomas Straussler, murdered half his family, and forced the remnants to flee to Singapore. Next came the Japanese Imperial Army, which, less than two years later, invaded Singapore, sending Tom's mother, Martha (his father stayed behind, and was never seen again), on a refugee boat to India with her two young sons.

...At 68, he is still discovering himself. When he was a boy, his mother drew a veil over the family's past. There had been a Jewish grandmother, she said, and this was why they had to leave Czechoslovakia. Only relatively recently did he learn the fully story.

His whole family was Jewish. Most of his relatives had been murdered in the death camps. His father, once the house doctor at the Bata shoe factory in Zlin, had been killed in a Japanese air raid. Some years ago, after a visit to Czechoslovakia, he wrote movingly of meeting an elderly woman, a former Bata employee, whose gashed hand had been stitched by Dr Straussler. "I touch it. In that moment, I am surprised by grief, a small catching up of all the grief I owe. I have nothing which came from my father, nothing he owned or touched, but here is his trace, a small scar."
I would like to think that books that are obviously engineered from the get-go to be de facto catalogs for some corporation's catalog of products will set off young kids' bullshit meters. But I wonder... (See also: The dark side of copyright law.) As for the rest of us, insert your own reason why this is insane and get on with it.

Friday, May 19, 2006

Indie booksellers, rest in peace

Alas, much of this piece is spot-on, even though it stings to admit it:
The real change in the book market is not the big guy vs. the little guy, or chain vs. indie stores. Rather, it's the reader's greater impatience, a symptom of our amazing literary (and televisual) plenitude. In the modern world we are more pressed for time, and we face a greater diversity of cultural choices. It was easy to finish Tolstoy's War and Peace when there were few other books around and it was hard to find them. Today, finishing it means forgoing many other options at our fingertips. As a result, we tend to consume ideas in smaller bits, a proposition that (in another context) economists labeled the "Alchian and Allen theorem." Long, serious novels are less culturally central than they were 100 years ago. Blogs are on the rise, and most readers prefer the ones with the shorter posts.
This and other corresponding stories were brought on by the news of the closing of Cody's, a venerable independent bookstore located in San Francisco. The nice thing about independently-owned and operated stores is, yes, having a personal contact at a brick-and-mortar establishment who knows a thing or two about what the store sells and can point inquisitive customers in the right direction, or, alternatively, turn them on to something they might not have thought about or heard of before.

Given the advent of the Internet, however, specialized knowledge of literature -- and books, in general -- has become almost a moot point. Word-of-mouth is one of the strongest selling points of any book, simply because it depends largely upon an interpersonal recommendation: when someone whose tastes you respect mentions a book in a positive context, you're more likely to seek it out. Cowen is smart to point out that forums on the Net -- reader reviews at Amazon, for example, as well as litblogs -- have taken this idea into a new medium. If someone over at Bookslut or Conversational Reading can make a good case for reading XY's new book, then, well, why not check it out?

Yes, e-commerce will probably be the death of the traditional independent bookstore. I'm probably like most people who like to read: my budget is limited, so I'm more likely to buy used books, or shop online for the discounts. It's extremely rare for me to pay full cover price for a book I'm looking for, be it at an independent OR chain bookstore, simply because it doesn't make a whole lot of fiscal sense to do so. It would seem, then, that the alternative to putting more money in the pockets of the behemoths is to apply the same philosophy that spurs you to shop outside the mainstream to e-commerce, as well: buying books from individuals on Amazon Marketplace or eBay, or shopping at independent online booksellers like Powells or discount retailers like BookCloseouts.com.

Cowen is right: there's more out there now, meaning more avenues to explore and about a fraction of the time to explore them. Specialized knowledge of books and literature could either become a blessing or a liability; there was a widely-circulated piece in the May 14 New York Times Magazine called "Scan This Book!", by Kevin Kelly, a writer for Wired, that suggested the future of books would be not unlike that of an MP3 playlist. Knowledge of books, Kelly suggested, would become highly compartmentalized; subject matter could be cross-indexed to death, which is fine if you're looking for scads of information on one particular topic but, as Scott Esposito pointed out, could have the backlash effect of reducing the scope and vision of a particular book to a mere collection of loosely-associated parts. Probably the most appealing thing about a well-written book of any type is its potential to compress the world in all its contradictory glory between two cardboard covers; to contain multitudes. In a world driven and governed by soundbites, that's harder and harder to accomplish.

Friday, May 05, 2006

The dark side of copyright law

There was a story in The New York Times in November 2005 called "The Goat at Saks and Other Marketing Tales" which detailed Saks Fifth Avenue's development of an illustrated children's book called Cashmere If You Can, about a young girl and her pet herd of Mongolian goats who call the roof of the famed department store home. What distinguished this particular publication from the rest was that the book did not originate from the mind of an individual author. Rather, it was commissioned by a Saks marketing executive, ostensibly with the intent of creating a piece of profitable fiction which would showcase the store within its pages. Another recent story in the Times called "First, Plot and Character. Then, Find an Author" (4/27/06) detailed a similar strategy by Alloy Entertainment, a young-adult publishing company.

Product placement used to be a joke; now it's so ubiquitous that brands no longer need to pay for the right for their product to be showcased in a book, film or TV show. These days, they simply take their product and build the edifice of a book, film or TV show around it. The unfortunate downside to this approach has been demonstrated quite clearly of late, with the revelation that a 19-year-old Harvard student, Kaavya Viswanathan, appears to have lifted large chunks of her recently-published book How Opal Mehta Got Kissed, Got Wild, and Got a Life from preexisting works by author Megan McCafferty and also, to a lesser extent, authors Sophie Kinsella, Meg Cabot and even Salman Rushdie.

Copyright law was ostensibly created to protect the rights of the individual creator of any artistic work from unlawful reuse. In one sense, it's beneficial for the creator because it ensures that they'll be fiscally rewarded for their hard work in creating something that people want to purchase and experience. The flipside, however, is that it could conceivably box the creators of future works into smaller and smaller compartments. Exploitation of copyright law can be seen particularly clearly when the "estate" of any given author claims ownership of material and demands damages because they believe that the originator of the idea owns it until the end of time. This is an idea that has always seemed a little bit absurd to me; while the creator certainly deserves the recognition and reward for the work they do, that doesn't mean their family or friends or distant relations automatically deserve to get a slice of the pie.

How, then, do you claim ownership of material when a corporation commissions it? Is the future of copyright law such that originality is sliced-and-diced into a number of no-fly zones that could limit an author's ability to touch upon certain subject areas, or even certain ideas? A fascinating recent documentary called The Corporation detailed how lawyers in the early 18th century exploited a loophole in the 14th Amendment that enabled them to declare corporations an individual "person" that's entitled to legal rights normally granted solely to flesh-and-blood individuals. As detailed by the excellent writer Glenn Erickson, also known as DVD Savant, in his review of the film at DVDTalk.com:

Corporations in the first half of the 18th century were chartered when the resources to construct things like bridges could only be found in private hands. The creation of legal "persons" was meant to protect individuals from undue liability in public projects, usually with strictly defined limits. Clever lawyers used the 14th Amendment - designed to extend the rights of recently freed slaves - to extend the rights of corporate persons as well, permitting such unintended things as one corporation buying another. Living persons cannot buy and sell one another, but corporate "persons" can.
If corporate power can extend into the intangible realm of ideas, where can creativity go without being boxed in by misuse of legal power? Obviously there's a line between the appropriation of a preexisting idea for one's own ends and the callous exploitation of outright plagiarism. Viswanathan's case has made such a splash because she was initially perceived to be a sort of wunderkind; a young Ivy League college student who had wrangled her own lucrative book contract by what appeared to be pure, unadulterated talent. But the situation becomes more complicated once you consider that the work itself bore the heavy influence of corporate control. I don't claim to be an expert on copyright law -- or of any law, for that matter; I'll leave that to my law-school friends. But it's increasingly disturbing to see so much influence wielded by corporations in areas that should be outside their realm of influence.

Wednesday, April 19, 2006

Here's what real criticism looks like

It's always nice to read a well-written book review. Two have caught my eye of late:

  • Malcolm Gladwell reviews Charles Tilly's Why? at The New Yorker.
Gladwell returns, this time training his lens on humanity's innate need for justification:
When we say that two parties in a conflict are “talking past each other,” this is what we mean: that both sides have a legitimate attachment to mutually exclusive reasons. Proponents of abortion often rely on a convention (choice) and a technical account (concerning the viability of a fetus in the first trimester). Opponents of abortion turn the fate of each individual fetus into a story: a life created and then abruptly terminated. Is it any surprise that the issue has proved to be so intractable? If you believe that stories are the most appropriate form of reason-giving, then those who use conventions and technical accounts will seem morally indifferent—regardless of whether you agree with them. And, if you believe that a problem is best adjudicated through conventions or technical accounts, it is hard not to look upon storytellers as sensationalistic and intellectually unserious. By Tilly’s logic, abortion proponents who want to engage their critics will have to become better storytellers—and that, according to the relational principles of such reason-giving, may require them to acknowledge an emotional connection between a mother and a fetus.

...Tilly argues that these conflicts are endemic to the legal system. Laws are established in opposition to stories. In a criminal trial, we take a complicated narrative of cause and effect and match it to a simple, impersonal code: first-degree murder, or second-degree murder, or manslaughter. The impersonality of codes is what makes the law fair. But it is also what can make the legal system so painful for victims, who find no room for their voices and their anger and their experiences. Codes punish, but they cannot heal.
Much of the time Flaubert's influence is too familiar to be visible. We so expect it that we hardly remark of good prose that it favors the telling and brilliant detail; that it privileges a high degree of visual noticing; that it maintains an unsentimental composure and knows how to withdraw, like a good valet, from superfluous commentary; that it judges good and bad neutrally; that it seeks out the truth, even at the cost of repelling us; and that the author's fingerprints on all this are, paradoxically, traceable but not visible. You can find some of this in Defoe or Austen or Balzac, but not all of it until Flaubert. And after Flaubert, it sometimes seems, this is all you can find.
This really makes me want to read Madame Bovary now. It's been sitting on my shelf for months now, tempting me. That's the great thing about Wood's essays; they charge you up with the appetite for rediscovery. He published a marvelous collection of them in 2000 called The Broken Estate: Essays on Literature and Belief; there's a particularly sharp essay on Nikolai Gogol's work which is endemic of his approach on the whole: fond yet unsentimental, practical yet hopeful. He doesn't hold much sympathy, however, for modernists like Toni Morrison or Thomas Pynchon (and he makes a strong argument for it, too), but you can't have everything in life.

Tuesday, September 20, 2005

Language, longevity and book clubs

  • Natalie Angier sniffs around the notion of “dirty words” at the New York Times.
The notion of language being obscene and/or disgusting became utterly irrelevant to me the first time I ever saw what a bullet did to a living thing. Of course, if you torture and/or kill in the name of your country or your god, you’re in the clear. Humanity baffles me.
  • Carlos Fuentes fetes Cervantes’ Don Quixote and its influence on the literary form known as the novel.
I’ll be glad when Quixote’s 400th anniversary year is over so I can get back to enjoying the book again. The problem with something like Quixote is not that it’s overrated, per se, but that it sometimes doesn’t quite bear the weight of all the innovations it’s supposed to have ushered into existence. Nonetheless, Fuentes makes a number of good points about a novel’s shelf life, and how it can live far beyond its creator’s expectations.
  • Slate’s Fall Fiction Week closes out with Meghan O’Rourke’s adventures in unraveling The Sound and the Fury, with a little help from a certain book-loving talk-show host.
Either you go with Faulkner, or you don’t. Read this piece either way; O’Rourke’s take on him is insightful and practical. Oprah’s book club choices have been hit-and-miss with me -- most of the ones I’ve read, like Midwives, The Reader, Ellen Foster and House of Sand and Fog, didn’t add up to much -- so I have to give her credit for going with a trifecta of modernist classics that require a bit more effort to get through. But I daresay I kinda preferred it when she was introducing new authors to the scene. So much for that... thanks a lot, Franzen.

(Update, 9/22/05: The new book club selection from The Oprah is James Frey's memoir A Million Little Pieces. Ehhh... fine.)

Wednesday, August 31, 2005

Dispatch from hell on earth

Haunting details from an article in the New York Times by Ralph Blumenthal, about rescue workers in New Orleans:

A truckload of National Guard troops said they had helped rush to the hospital a woman who delivered a baby in the back of a state wildlife and fisheries truck.

A man stepped out of a rescue boat cradling a piglet.

Pauline Stauss, 80, was rescued with a dog and three cats that she was keeping for her daughter.

Kate Guelfo, 83, was the first of five in her flooded house to be rescued. With just one spot available in the rescue boat, her housemates pushed her out the window to safety, agreeing themselves to await later rescue. Ms. Guelfo's arm was black and blue, but she was grateful.

Natural gas bubbled up from severed lines. Petroleum fires flickered on the water.

Power lines dangled onto roads, and telephone poles teetered, snapped like matchsticks.

Levees breached in several places poured water from Lake Pontchartrain into the city.

Battling the waters are hundreds of emergency workers mobilized by FEMA, including the Coast Guard and incident teams from Texas, Missouri and Tennessee.

The teams, 70-member groups of firefighters and medical specialists, arrive with 18-wheelers and other trucks loaded with generators, chainsaws, tents and dogs that can sniff out the living and the dead.

As of Tuesday night, they reported saving 315 people, including a 400-pound woman who was reached by cutting through a roof and a belligerent woman who had run out of methadone.
Let the editorial finger-pointing begin, hindsight being perfect and all.

This is rumor control. Here are the facts.

In the meantime, donate if you can.